Home / News / theScore Hit with a $200,000 AGCO Fine Over Misleading Cash Out Offer

theScore Hit with a $200,000 AGCO Fine Over Misleading Cash Out Offer

Affiliate Disclosure: OntarioGamers.ca earns commission when you sign up through our links — at no extra cost to you. This does not influence our editorial recommendations.

Toronto-based theScore was penalized with a $200,000 fine by the Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario (AGCO) after it failed to honour a six-figure cash out. 

Announced October 6, 2026, PENN Entertainment subsidiary, Score Media and Gaming, was accused of failing to meet Standard 4.07 of the Registrar’s Standards for Internet Gaming, which requires licensed operators to present gaming opportunities in an accurate way and to be honoured as described. The regulator alleges that theScore breached Section 3.8 of the Gaming Control Act, 1992 by failing to meet the required standards. 

Although this is the first time the AGCO has imposed its maximum monetary penalty on a licensed operator, it is not the largest fine in the regulator’s history. That distinction belongs to FanDuel, which received a $350,000 penalty for failing to properly detect and report suspicious betting activity involving international table tennis matches.

The $1,000 Multi-Leg Parlay Behind the AGCO Penalty

The incident dates back to March 14, 2025, when a player placed a $1,000 multi-leg parlay on theScore Bet Ontario, covering NHL, NBA and NCAA basketball games scheduled for that day. According to the AGCO, the bet had the potential to return more than $1 million if every selection came through.

With all but one leg settled in the player’s favour, theScore offered a cash-out of approximately $380,000. The bettor accepted the offer immediately, but the sportsbook rejected the transaction during its automated verification process after the odds had changed. Cash-out offers can fluctuate with live betting odds, meaning the amount displayed to the player was no longer available when the transaction was processed.

Four minutes later, theScore made another cash-out offer, this time worth nearly $100,000. The player accepted again, but the sportsbook failed to honour this offer as well. The parlay eventually settled as a loss, leaving the bettor without any payout.

After reviewing the case, the AGCO found that neither of the cash-out amounts offered to the player could actually be honoured. 

theScore’s Second Major Ontario Penalty

AGCO’s $200,000 enforcement action against the Toronto-based company marks the second major regulatory blow in Ontario. 

Back in October 2025, the regulator slapped the licensed operator with a $105,000 penalty for over alleged failures to meet responsible gambling and player protection requirements. An AGCO review found that the operator failed to recognize warning signs of potential gambling harm in a customer’s betting activity, despite the player wagering approximately $2.5 million and losing around $230,000 over eight months.

The review also highlighted several missed opportunities for intervention. During this period, the customer reportedly lost about $100,000 in their first month alone, showed signs of distress when communicating with a theScore VIP host and repeatedly requested bonuses. The player also submitted income documents containing inaccurate information and displayed signs of chasing losses.

According to the AGCO, theScore did not respond adequately to these warning signs, despite its obligations under the Registrar’s Standards for Internet Gaming to monitor player behaviour and take appropriate steps to protect customers from gambling-related harm.

Supreme Court of Canada Hears Ontario Online Poker Liquidity Case

On October 7, 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada heard arguments concerning Ontario’s plans to link its peer-to-peer games with players from outside Canada. 

The appeal, known as Atlantic Lottery Corporation et al. v. Attorney General of Ontario, stems from a 2025 Ontario Court of Appeal decision that backed the plan. Four provincial lottery corporations challenged that ruling and took the case to the Supreme Court of Canada.

With arguments now complete, The Supreme Court is currently considering its decision. No date has been confirmed for the court’s ruling, meaning Ontario players stay in the ring-fenced market. However, its decision determines if Ontario can offer international player pools and how other provinces, including Alberta, approach shared liquidity. 

Senior Casino & Slots Writer
Vanessa Phillimore is an experienced online casino content writer with a passion for clear, trustworthy guides that connect Ontario players with safe, regulated gaming. From casino and slot reviews to industry news and responsible-gambling advice, she pairs careful research with an engaging writing style that keeps readers informed.
Responsible Gambling 19+ only. Gambling involves financial risk. Only play with money you can afford to lose. All operators listed are AGCO-registered for Ontario players. Problem gambling help: ConnexOntario 1-866-531-2600 (free, confidential, 24/7). Full responsible gambling resources.